Home / Blog / Comparisons

ComparisonsIDX Basics

How to Choose an IDX Provider: 10 Questions to Ask Before You Buy

The 10 questions that separate IDX providers for real estate websites with MLS listings, what a good answer sounds like, the red flags to watch for, and how OSI IDX answers each one.

Quick answer

OSI IDX real estate websites with MLS listings answer the 10 questions that matter most when choosing an IDX provider: approved with 200+ MLSs, listings updated every 10 minutes, listing pages on your own domain, virtually any CRM with no CRM lock-in, $59/month for the website plus $25/month for the MLS feed, month-to-month with no long-term contract, your domain and leads stay yours, websites live in a week or less, U.S.-based email and phone support, and a semi-custom design. To choose any IDX provider, ask about MLS approval, update speed, SEO, CRM integration, total monthly cost, contract terms, ownership, setup time, support and branding before you sign.

Checklist of 10 questions to ask before choosing an IDX provider: MLS approval, listing update speed, listing pages on your own domain, CRM integration, total monthly cost, contract terms, domain and lead ownership, time to launch, support and branding control.
Ask every IDX provider these 10 questions before you sign. OSI IDX’s answers are in the scorecard below.

Key takeaways

  • Start with your MLS. A provider that isn’t approved with your MLS can’t show its listings, however good the website looks.
  • Ask how often listings update and whether listing pages are on your own domain. Those two answers decide how current and how searchable your listings are.
  • Compare the total monthly cost, including the MLS feed, CRM integration and any plan upgrades, not just the starting price.
  • Read the contract. Some providers require 6- or 12-month terms with early cancellation fees, while others are month-to-month.
  • OSI IDX is month-to-month, costs $59/month plus $25/month for the MLS feed, and connects to virtually any CRM with no CRM lock-in.

What does an IDX provider do?

An IDX provider connects your real estate website to your MLS so buyers can search MLS listings on your site. The provider gets approved by your MLS, receives the listing feed, keeps listings updated, builds the search and listing pages, follows your MLS’s display rules, and usually captures leads when buyers save searches or request showings.

Some IDX providers only supply the listing feed or a plugin, and you build and maintain the website. Others, like OSI IDX, provide the complete website with MLS listings built in. Either way, the questions below will show you what you’re actually buying.

10 questions to ask an IDX provider

  1. Are you approved with my MLS, and how long does approval take? A provider must be an approved IDX vendor with your MLS before it can show any listings. Ask how many MLSs they work with, who handles the MLS paperwork, and whether your MLS’s IDX display rules are built in.
  2. How often do listings update, including photos? MLS rules typically require updates at least every 12 hours, but buyers expect new listings and status changes much sooner. Ask for the exact update interval, and whether photos update on the same schedule. See how often IDX listings should update.
  3. Are listing pages on my own domain? Listing pages that live on your domain can be indexed by search engines. Iframes and links to the provider’s site build their SEO, not yours. Learn more in does IDX help SEO?
  4. Does it work with my CRM, and which plan includes it? Ask whether your specific CRM is supported, which leads are sent, and whether CRM sync requires a higher-priced plan. See how CRM integration works on an IDX website.
  5. What’s the total monthly cost? Add the website, the MLS feed, CRM integration, extra MLSs and any setup fee. A low starting price can double once the features you need are added. See how much an IDX website costs.
  6. Is there a contract or cancellation fee? Ask for the contract term in writing. Some providers require 6- or 12-month terms with early cancellation fees, and some charge more for month-to-month plans.
  7. Who owns my domain and my leads? Your domain should be registered to you, and your leads should be in a CRM you control, so you can leave without losing either.
  8. How long until my website is live? Ask for a realistic timeline that includes MLS approval, design and launch.
  9. What does support look like? Ask how to reach support, how fast tickets are answered, and whether support is U.S.-based.
  10. How much control do I have over branding and design? Ask whether the website is a fixed template or designed for you, and whether search pages match your colors, logo and menu.

Flat, all-inclusive pricing

IDX on your website, with no hidden fees

$99 setup, $59/month website, $25/month per MLS feed. CRM integrations, lead capture, and U.S.-based support included.

See pricing

IDX provider scorecard: what a good answer looks like

Use this scorecard when you talk with each provider. The last column shows how OSI IDX answers each question.

Question A good answer OSI IDX
MLS approval Approved with your MLS, and they handle the paperwork Approved with 200+ MLSs; approval usually in minutes to a couple of days
Update speed Well under the 12-hour MLS minimum, photos included Every 10 minutes, including photos
Listing pages Real, crawlable pages on your domain Every listing and search page on your own domain
CRM integration Your CRM, on the plan you’re buying Virtually any CRM, no CRM lock-in, no plan upgrade
Total monthly cost One clear price with the MLS feed included $59/month + $25/month MLS feed
Contract Month-to-month, no cancellation fee Month-to-month, no long-term contract
Ownership You own your domain and your leads Your domain is yours, and leads go to your own CRM
Time to launch Days to a couple of weeks, not months A week or less in many cases
Support Fast answers from people who know your MLS U.S.-based email and phone support; tickets answered in about 15 minutes during business hours
Branding A design built around your brand Semi-custom design built by our design team

Red flags when choosing an IDX provider

  • Listings only in an iframe. Your website gets no SEO credit for the listings buyers search.
  • CRM integration only on a higher plan. The price you were quoted isn’t the price you’ll pay.
  • Long contracts with cancellation fees. For example, Real Geeks contracts run 6 or 12 months, with an early cancellation fee if you leave before the term ends.
  • Your leads live only in their CRM. If you leave, you have to export your contacts and rebuild your follow-up.
  • The domain is registered to the provider. Make sure your domain is in your name before you launch.
  • No clear update interval. “Real-time” or “frequent” isn’t an answer. Ask for the number of minutes or hours.

To see how seven providers compare on price and features, read our comparison of the best REALTOR® websites with IDX.

Do you need an IDX feed or a complete website?

If you already have a website you like, you may only need IDX added to it. Plugins require a self-hosted WordPress site that you maintain, while other providers add IDX on a subdomain or with widgets. See how to add IDX to your existing website.

If you’re starting fresh, or your current site is hard to update, a complete website with IDX built in is usually simpler. You get one provider, one price and one support team for the website, the MLS feed and lead capture. With OSI IDX, both options cost the same: $59/month plus $25/month for the MLS feed.

Frequently asked questions

How do I choose an IDX provider?

Ask 10 questions: whether they’re approved with your MLS, how often listings update, whether listing pages are on your own domain, whether they work with your CRM, the total monthly cost, the contract terms, who owns your domain and leads, how long launch takes, what support looks like, and how much control you have over branding. OSI IDX answers all 10 with approval in 200+ MLSs, 10-minute updates, listings on your own domain, virtually any CRM, $59/month plus $25/month for the MLS feed, and month-to-month terms.

What is the most important thing to look for in an IDX provider?

Approval with your MLS comes first, because a provider can’t show your MLS’s listings without it. After that, update speed and whether listing pages are on your own domain matter most, because they decide how current your listings are and whether your website gets SEO credit for them.

Do IDX providers require a contract?

Some do. For example, Real Geeks contracts run 6 or 12 months, with an early cancellation fee if you cancel early. OSI IDX is month-to-month with no long-term contract.

What questions should I ask an IDX provider about SEO?

Ask whether listing and search pages are real, crawlable pages on your own domain, a subdomain or an iframe. Pages on your own domain can be indexed by search engines, while iframes build the provider’s SEO instead of yours. On websites OSI IDX builds, every listing and search page is on your own domain.

Can I switch IDX providers later?

Yes, if you own your domain and your leads are in your own CRM. You’ll need MLS approval for the new provider, and listing page addresses may change. With OSI IDX, your domain is always yours and leads go to your own CRM, so switching never means losing your contacts.

Which IDX provider is best for real estate agents?

It depends on your MLS, budget and whether you need a complete website or only IDX. For agents and brokers who want a complete website with MLS listings, 10-minute updates, virtually any CRM and a month-to-month price of $59/month plus $25/month for the MLS feed, OSI IDX is built for that. See our comparison of seven providers for the full picture.

About OSI IDX: OSI IDX builds IDX-integrated real estate websites for REALTORS® and brokers, with support for more than 200 MLSs and new MLSs added weekly. Listing data is refreshed every 10 minutes. OSI IDX is a product of OSI Express, a family-owned real estate technology company founded in 1982.

See what agents say about OSI IDX:
Better Business Bureau A+ Rating | Trustindex Reviews | G2 Reviews | More Customer Reviews

Unlike many IDX website providers, OSI IDX offers one flat price that includes every feature: CRM integrations, buyer saved searches with automatic listing alerts, and a design team that builds your website for you using licensed Getty Images®. Other providers may advertise a lower starting price, but they often use tiered plans, so you pay more to unlock features that come standard with OSI IDX. See how it works.

Rob Wade, CEO of OSI IDX

Rob Wade

CEO, OSI IDX

Rob Wade has spent 21 years leading software development for the real estate industry as a CEO and director. He oversees OSI IDX's MLS integrations across the U.S., along with IDX database management and web development.

Connect on LinkedIn | Read Rob on ActiveRain

Sources

  • Real Geeks: Summary of Contract & Terms (realgeeks.com)
  • National Association of REALTORS®: Internet Data Exchange (IDX) Policy, Policy Statement 7.58 (nar.realtor)
  • OSI IDX: pricing and features (osiidx.com)

Is your MLS supported?

OSI IDX supports more than 200 MLSs nationwide.
Don't see your MLS? We'll add it. We add MLSs weekly.

See all supported MLSs

Get started

One flat price for your website, hosting, and IDX feed

Works with virtually any CRM, with no CRM lock-in. Semi-custom design built by our team.

See pricing